ResearchPublished

Professor’s Research, Copycat or Serena’s Choice: With All Three in Hand, Which Should You Play?

Compare three Supporters using exact draw probabilities: your first turn going first, finding one card, completing a two-card combo, and keeping a piece already in hand.

You have , and in hand and have not played a Supporter yet. Which do you play this turn?

Finding one Evolution card and finding both and an Evolution card call for different choices, even with the same hand and deck sizes. If you already hold one required card, keeping it also matters.

In the comparison below, you can change your deck size, hand sizes and target counts. Set Target 2 to 0 to find Target 1 only; set it to at least 1 to show the chance of getting at least one of each of two different targets.

Compare the three Supporters

No targets are currently in your hand. Targets 1 and 2 are different cards. Additional draws and searches are excluded.

Chance to add at least one Target 1 to your hand

Chance to add at least one Target 1 to your hand
SupporterSuccess probabilityHand size after use
27.5%6
40.5%4
39.6%5

Bottom line: the highest-probability card for each goal

Here are the results for our baseline: 10 cards in your deck, 5 in your hand and 5 in your opponent’s hand.

This turn’s goalHighest
Find one type of card (2 copies in the deck)37.8%60.4%53.3%
Find both required cards, with neither in hand2.2%11.0%0%
Complete a pair with one card already in hand20.0%11.0%30.0%

’s probability varies greatly with your opponent’s hand size and the number of cards you return. With an opponent’s hand of 4, as on your first turn going first, its advantage over when finding one target almost disappears. Below, we vary the conditions case by case.

How the three cards differ, and our assumptions

The three cards compared

Click a card image to open its details

Professor's Research Professor Oak
Copycat
Serena's Choice
CardEffectOther cards in handHand size afterward (starting with 5)
Draw 2 cardsKept6
Shuffle your hand into your deck, then draw a card for each card in your opponent’s handReturned to the deckSame as the opponent’s hand size
Look at the top 3 cards of your deck, put 1 of them into your hand, and shuffle the rest back into your deckKept5

draws from a larger deck after your hand has been returned. The you play is not returned: playing it from a hand of 5 returns 4 cards. With 10 cards initially in the deck, you therefore draw from 14.

  • Baseline: your deck has 10 cards, your hand has 5 after the normal draw, including all three Supporters, and your opponent has 5 cards in hand.

  • Success means having the required cards in hand immediately after the Supporter resolves. Additional draws or searches from cards you obtain are excluded.

  • The fixed examples exclude situations where the hand limit or an insufficient deck reduces the number of cards drawn.

Case 1: your first turn going first

Both players begin with exactly one Basic Pokémon in the Active Spot. You go first and have taken your normal draw: your hand has 5 cards, your deck has 14, and your opponent’s hand has 4.

You cannot evolve on your first turn, so you are looking for a card not in hand, such as an additional Basic Pokémon for your Bench.

Card played1 target copy in the deck2 target copies in the deckHand size afterward
14.3%27.5%6
22.2%40.5%4
21.4%39.6%5

returns 4 cards and draws 4 from 18, so its advantage over is less than 1 percentage point. Yet your hand drops to 4 cards, and and go back into the deck.

is a strong choice here, preserving and for later turns. draws more cards if you save it for a turn when your opponent’s hand is larger.

Case 2: finding one type of card

Baseline: 2 target copies in the deck

In the baseline, draws 5 from 14 for a 60.4% success rate, above at 53.3% and at 37.8%.

has a lower success rate than but gives you 2 cards, including the target when successful. If the second card is also useful, account for that value (Case 5).

depends on the opponent’s hand and how many cards you return

With 10 cards in the deck and 2 targets, changing only your opponent’s hand gives the following probabilities; your hand stays at 5. stays at 37.8% and at 53.3%.

Opponent’s hand3456
39.6%50.5%60.4%69.2%

Here, beats when the opponent has at least 5 cards. That threshold also depends on how many cards you return. With an opponent’s hand of 4, reducing the other cards in your hand before gives these results.

Cards returned by 432
Deck drawn from4 from 144 from 134 from 12
50.5%53.8%57.6%

Each card fewer you return adds roughly 3–4 percentage points; returning 3 cards beats at 53.3%. Since you keep and in hand, you must return at least 2 cards.

For , consider both how many cards you draw and how large the deck is when you draw them.

Case 3: finding two required cards, with neither in hand

You need two different cards, such as and a Stage 2 Pokémon. The Basic Pokémon was already in play before this turn, so can be used. Call the required cards A and B: each has 1 copy in a deck of 10, and neither is in hand.

Card playedChance of having both A and B
2.2%
11.0%
0%

adds only 1 card, so it cannot obtain both this turn. must draw exactly A and B. Even , the best of the three here, succeeds only 11.0% of the time.

If the combo can wait, you can spread the search over two turns. has a 53.3% chance to see A or B among 3 cards. If it finds one, next turn’s normal draw plus draws 3 from a deck of 9, with a 33.3% chance to find the other card. The chance of completing the pair within two turns is at least 17.8% (53.3% × 33.3%, excluding next-turn attempts after finds neither). This exceeds ’s chance this turn, assuming the Basic Pokémon you plan to evolve survives your opponent’s turn.

Case 4: already holding one combo piece

You hold 1 copy of A and are looking for B, which has 1 copy in the deck. Other conditions match the baseline.

Card playedChance of having both A and B
20.0%
11.0%
30.0%

has a 35.7% chance of drawing B itself, higher than at 30.0%. But it returns A too, so both A and B must be drawn again. The chance of completing the combo drops to 11.0%, as in Case 3.

Keeping a required card already in hand directly improves the chance of completing the combo. improves if another A remains in the deck or the opponent has more cards in hand.

Case 5: how many useful cards will you have for next turn?

So far we have measured the chance of finding specific cards. To compare the whole hand, compare the average number of cards in hand after the effect that you want to use by next turn. We call these useful cards, including Supporters you keep.

Using the baseline, compare two distributions with 7 useful cards in total among the remaining 4 hand cards and the 10 deck cards.

Where the useful cards are
Mostly in hand (3 of the remaining 4; 4 of 10 in deck)3.802.503.83
Mostly in deck (1 of the remaining 4; 6 of 10 in deck)2.202.501.97

mixes hand and deck, so the expected number is 2.50 useful cards regardless of their original location. If most are already in hand, keeping them with or leaves you with over one more useful card. Here, gives the highest average when the remaining hand contains at most 1 useful card.

and have similar averages here. leaves 6 cards in hand, one more than , while lets you select the highest-priority card among the 3 you see.

Applying this: actions before your Supporter

Reduce your hand before

As in Case 2, using an Item or putting a Basic Pokémon onto the Bench to reduce your hand by 1 improves by roughly 3–4 percentage points in this example. and are unchanged. Weigh those points against spending a Bench slot and giving your opponent another target.

When removing deck cards, recount the targets too

Getting a Basic Pokémon from the deck with or a similar card first reduces the deck and improves your chance of finding an Evolution. If the removed card itself was a target, the remaining target count also falls.

If the searched card stays in your hand, returns it to the deck too. If you can Bench it first, do so before playing .

When unsure, check in this order

  1. Do you need any one target card this turn, or both of two different cards?

  2. How many required cards are already in your hand? Holding one makes less attractive.

  3. For , check the opponent’s hand size and your deck size after returning your hand.

Appendix: the probability calculations

We count combinations for draws without replacement and round to one decimal place, or two in Case 5.C(n, r) is the number of ways to choose r cards from n.

Chance of finding at least one target

When drawing d cards from a deck of N containing K targets, the probability is1 − C(N − K, d) / C(N, d). Use d = 2 for and d = 3 for , since seeing a target among the top 3 lets you choose it.

With a hand of H before use and an opponent’s hand of M, draws M cards from a deck ofN + H − 1 cards. Include any targets returned from your hand in the target count.

  • Baseline (2 target copies): 1 − C(8, 2) / C(10, 2) = 37.8%, 1 − C(8, 3) / C(10, 3) = 53.3%, 1 − C(12, 5) / C(14, 5) = 60.4%

  • Case 1 (2 target copies): 1 − C(12, 2) / C(14, 2) = 27.5%, 1 − C(12, 3) / C(14, 3) = 39.6%, 1 − C(16, 4) / C(18, 4) = 40.5%. With 1 target copy, use2 / 14,3 / 14,4 / 18

Chance of drawing both A and B, with one copy each

C(N − 2, d − 2) / C(N, d) gives this probability. For ,C(8, 0) / C(10, 2) = 2.2%, C(12, 3) / C(14, 5) = 11.0%. If you initially hold one piece, returning it with again leaves one of each in the deck, giving the same value.

The two-turn route in Case 3 multiplies the chance that sees A or B in 3 cards,1 − C(8, 3) / C(10, 3) = 53.3%, by the chance of finding the remaining card among 3 draws from 9 next turn (1 normal draw and 2 from ),3 / 9 = 33.3%.

Expected useful-card count (Case 5)

With h useful cards in the remaining hand and U useful cards in a deck of N, the averages are: h + 2U / N, h + 1 − C(N − U, 3) / C(N, 3), M × (h + U) / (N + H − 1).

Back to articles